A couple of weeks ago I received a rather surprising email request from the Natural History Museum in London. The request was for some data on the correspondence network of
Allan Octavian Hume. Many years ago, I had put together all the names of correspondents cited in his (and Marshall's) three volume "Game birds of India, Burmah and Ceylon" along with their locations. Putting this on a map gave a view of how Hume managed to get information from across India without actually having to expend too much of his own personal energies to obtain the data (mainly in the form of specimens). In hindsight,
that map was rather poorly prepared.
 |
| Scatter plot and a density plot showing the distribution and numbers of Hume correspondents |
The rather exceptional body of work that Hume produced included an enormous collection of (about 82,000) bird specimens and associated information. Around 1884 he donated this entire collection to the British Museum (today the Natural History Museum). This was prompted by the theft of his life-time of notes and manuscripts, an event that led him to give up ornithology. He then diverted his energies towards the Indian National Congress (which too he gave up due to the infighting and lack of enthusiasm among Indians). Anyway, I discovered the raw data used to create the map and found it worth re-examining. So this time round I was able to unify the plots and include labels, but it involved a lot of jugglery with tools that included Excel, R, GIMP and Inkscape. The data that is accessible for a researcher in India is actually extremely limited and someone with access to the actual specimens in the Natural History Museum should be able to do an enormously better job.
 |
| The dataset can be downloaded here |
Many of Hume's contributors were in the Indian Civil Services or officers in the Army. These were evidently positions in which there was a lot of leisure and travel, allowing them to send specimens and notes to Hume, who then duly compiled them in his own amazing journal -
Stray Feathers - 10 volumes of which were produced before he gave up ornithology. An index volume was added by
Charles Chubb of the British Museum. All of these volumes are now available online. In an earlier publication I had mentioned that the map suggests why Hume did not bump into either the Eastern Ghats form of
Abbott's Babbler or
Jerdon's Courser. Even today, central and eastern India are dark regions, where few people observe birds.
These contributors sent information from locations where they were posted at different times in their career while some had their own network of contacts who sent in specimens from elsewhere. Although the vast majority were in the army or civil services, their background appear to have been quite varied and one can only imagine the the kind of correspondence they must have had. Some were sharpshooters or sportsmen, like
Duncan Home (DC Home) who died in the 1857 uprising and Colonel McMaster (McMaster also wrote under the pen-name of "Vagrant" for hunting periodicals like
The Field). There were other influences which are not directly evident. Many of them were trained in medicine at Edinburgh University which had its roots in ideas that emerged from the Scottish Enlightenment. They often shared common teachers, for instance
T C Jerdon who followed the fanciful
Quinarian system, and Charles Darwin, who was to drive the last nails into the coffin of that system, both studied under a Professor
Robert Jameson in Edinburgh, but that is not to say that the Professor's classes were interesting. Darwin actually
wrote that "
[T]he sole effect they produced on me was the determination never as long as I lived to read a book on Geology, or in any way to study the science." Jameson had however been involved with groups such as the
Plinian Society and
Wernerian Natural History Society, and the interactions among the participants in the lectures of these groups had influences on geology as well zoology in India. Jerdon was senior to Hume in ornithology and they held each other in high esteem.
Apart from these old-boys networks, there were also family ties.
Robert Wardlaw Ramsay (RGW Ramsay on the map) for instance was a good friend of Hume but his uncle
Lord Hay, an ornithological collector of eminence was considered by Hume as a mere "cabinet ornithologist" and the two sparred in their correspondence in the
Ibis. Hume's cousin, another Edinburgh physician, was
Edward Balfour,
the founder of several museums, compiler of the Cyclopedia of India and a pioneer of forest conservation. Balfour founded the Madras museum where he was succeeded by Dr.
George Bidie (Dr. G Bidie on the map above was also an Edinburgh physician) as curator (Superintendent was the official term used). Balfour was based in Madras which was also home to other indologists and polymaths like
Walter Elliot (after whom we have the Madras treeshrew
Anathana ellioti). Elliot's interests in zoology were secondary to his interest in numismatics, epigraphy and language. Elliot was mostly based out of Madras and this was the centre of a scholarly group that published in the
Madras Journal of Literature and Science. Elliot's sister-in-law was married to
PL Sclater. Sclater was the founder of the ornithological journal
The Ibis. Elliot's interest in Indian culture was possibly triggered by an immersive experience, early in his India career, as a prisoner of Kittur Rani Chennamma. Elliot wrote an obituary of Jerdon and his own was written by
Hugh Cleghorn (also an Edinburgh physician). Cleghorn can pretty much be considered the founding spirit behind the idea of a forest department in India in which he was followed by Colonel
R. H. Beddome (after whom we have Beddome's keelback ) who seems to have given most of his attention to the reptiles and amphibians.
|
|
Every journal of the period had to examine if they could survive and whether
they might be stepping on the toes of the Journal of the Asiatic Society of Bengal |
Another older scholarly group,
The Asiatic Society of Bengal, had its centre in Calcutta. Their early research also revolved around epigraphy and numismatics and their journal was founded by the
polymath,
James Prinsep. Shortlived though its editor was, it seems that the interests of the journal depended on its key people and zoology was rarely covered until
Edward Blyth became one of its underpaid staff. Blyth wrote many bird related papers, so much so that he complained to others about how he was sidelined and "
accused of being an ornithologist"! Both Blyth and Hume corresponded with another orientalist in the hills -
B H Hodgson in Nepal. A family friend of Hodgson's was
Thomas Malthus, the man who also influenced Darwin. Hodgson's life in India was however quite isolated but he seems to have kept up an enormous amount of correspondence and was extremely productive in his writing. He was also a friend of JD Hooker, the botanist, who was in turn a common friend of Darwin. Hodgson too seems to have at least in later life put his zoological pursuit behind his other interests, so much so that he became an expert on the Tibetan language and Buddhist philosophy. Hodgson however collected a large number of animal specimens. He also employed native artists to illustrate many of these specimens. About 1700 of these plates were lent to Hume and it would appear that little is known about their fate. Many naturalists in India appear to have employed native artists but most do not give them credit. Jerdon for instance trained
artists from Trichy (such as C V Kistnarajoo) but they often remain anonymous in his plates. An interesting exception here is a botanist friend of Cleghorn and Jerdon -
Robert Wight (Edinburgh physician again!). Wight found two exceptional artists by the name of Govindoo and Rungiah and they produced illustrations that Wight appreciated so much that he even named an orchid genus after Govindoo -
Govindooia (now
Tropidia). Wight's botany expanded on the earlier work of
William Roxburgh (Edinburgh physician!), a botanist who followed Colonel
Robert Kyd at the botanical garden in Calcutta. Roxburgh succeeded
Patrick Russell (Edinburgh physician famous for Russell's viper) as "Naturalist" at Madras. There were also some other earlier positions as "Naturalist" such as in the court of the Nawab of Arcot where Roxburgh's friend was
Johann Gerhard König, a student of Linnaeus. (Heard of curry leaf
Murraya koenigii ?)
Botany seems to have found itself a professional role thanks to the economic value of plants. Colonel Kyd (after whose family the locality of Kidderpore in Calcutta derives) for instance was able to sell the idea of botanical gardens to the East India Company without much trouble. Another bunch of professionals who also took an interest in zoology (esp. molluscs) were the geologists.
F.R. Mallet,
W Theobald,
T Oldham (Irish but studied under that same boring Professor Jameson in Edinburgh - the Oldham on the map however is a Captain Oldham who may have been a relative,
Oldham's son was also a geologist) and
V Ball (whose
father was an astronomer) among others were members of the Geological Survey of India - an organization that seems to have been dominated by Irishmen (
H B Medlicott of Gondwanaland fame and his brother,
JG Medlicott) although it also took in non-Irish paleontologists like
F. Stoliczka. Stoliczka is probably the most famous victim of altitude sickness and on that fatal expedition, was accompanied by Dr John Scully who appears on the Hume correspondence map. The passing of both Stoliczka and Blyth are recorded in volume 2 of Hume's
Stray Feathers. Zoology had a difficult start as a profession and many of the names we have come across so far joined hands to influence the creation of
The Fauna of British India. These included JD Hooker, Darwin, Huxley, J. Lubbock, WH Flower and PL Sclater. The editor they chose was the geologist
WT Blanford. Blanford's brother
HF Blanford was the founding spirit behind meteorology in India. The Indian Museum which came about from the museum of the Asiatic Society of Bengal where Blyth worked became the corpus on which the Zoological Survey of India worked. Staff at the Indian Museum included Dr
J. Anderson (Again Edinburgh physician!). Later workers here included PL Sclater's son,
WL Sclater. Another museum worker was
JA Murray at Karachi, who wrote a book, rather rare in its genre, called the
Edible and game birds of British India !
Army officers, botanists, geologist and men of medicine might appear to be the primary contributors but that is not the end.
W. E. Brooks was a remarkable engineer in the railways and he seems to have had his own interesting circle of friends (including
Mr. Hancock) but most importantly he seems to have quietly proceeded on the path of listening to bird song and examining differences between species. Through his method he made great progress in warbler identification as well as in separating members of the crow family. Unfortunately it seems that his pioneering approach was not accepted by Hume who saw skins as being the only reliable artefact. Brooks was so influenced by Hume that he named his youngest son after him.
Allan Brooks became one of the great bird artists and an ornithologist in his own right as well and in a little note (
Condor 44:157) he writes: "
... I am reminded of a similar controversy far back in the last century between my father, the late W. E. Brooks and my paternal sponsor, the late Allan Hume in the pages of the latter’s “Stray Feathers.” The controversy concerned the separation of the Hill Crow, Corvus intermedius, from the Jungle Crow, C. culminatus; my father insisted that their voices were quite distinct but Hume would clinch his argument for their identity with the claim that as the skins could not talk the birds could not be separated. ..." Other railways engineer - naturalist include H.R.P. Carter from Madras / Coonoor, H. P. Le Messurier (incorrectly noted as "
R.P."), and Henry Wenden from Poona.
Other minority professions include the missionaries - one member of which was Rev.
SB Fairbank (after whom we have
Trochalopteron fairbanki) from the Palni hills.
GP Sanderson, the son of a clergyman was later to write a lot on the big-game of southern India, so much so that Rudyard Kipling may have used him as a model for his
Petersen Sahib. The hills of Kodaikanal, Ootacamund and Simla were of course sanatoria frequented by wealthy colonial officers and they have more than a fair share of correspondents. One interesting member of this group is Miss
Cockburn, among the few women who contributed notes to Hume. She was also a bit of an artist and
her bird paintings from the Nilgiris were used in a calendar produced by the Natural History Museum. Her father,
M D Cockburn, was the district collector of Salem and
Catherine falls near Kotagiri is named after her mother. Their family was also involved in introducing coffee and a small number of coffee and tea planters also contributed to ornithology. One of these was
Louis Mandelli from Darjeeling. He seems to have been a bit of a bird collector who exchanged specimens with Hume. He is perhaps among the few that held a
very negative opinion of Hume who he claimed was stealing credit for discoveries and for being unfair in his specimen exchanges. Very little is known about
Mandelli and he appears to have led a troubled life that ended in suicide. Another contributor
J. Gammie was in charge of the government run cinchona plantations at Mangphu. The cinchona enterprise was within the government system that Hume oversaw as secretary of state.
JD Inverarity (Surat), a magistrate and others including
Charles Swinhoe were later to found the Bombay Natural History Society. Charles Swinhoe's brother was
Robert Swinhoe in Hong Kong, a diplomat. In this diplomat class of contributors we may include
R. Schomburgk and
OB St. John, their contributions being valuable for their travel to obscure locations. A. H. Hildebrand (Hildebrande on the map) was the first Superintendent of the Shan States and was responsible for the discovery of
Impatiens psittacina, which went viral on the Internet in recent times. Others who travelled on work included
H H Godwin-Austen (Godwin-Austen on the map and of K2/Mt. Godwin-Austen fame),
H J Elwes (who visited Hume in 1880 along with F D Godman of Godman-Salvin fame) and A W Chennell (Chennell on the map, also collected insect specimens, some like
Urolabida chennelli were named after him by W.L. Distant) who worked with the (Topographical) Survey of India. Oddly, the teaching establishment is also in a minority - Professor Harold Littledale at Baroda College stands out.
This map might give the wrong impression that India has been well examined for birds. No, this is only about how it was searched for "new" species - new in the sense that they were not known to the European experts - museum curators and collectors. That era is gone, now is the time where continuous monitoring and life-history studies have become the trend across the world, but that means local effort. Local effort needs support and training; which simply cannot happen if the best books are impossibly expensive and data, even that which is held by government bodies, is locked away in museums or stowed away in private collections. The situation is not improved by self-styled experts who sit smugly in their offices, jet across the country to make slick movies or write travelogues in glossy magazines either. Even in the 19th century it was recognized that knowledge was lacking in spite of this widespread collection of specimens. Brian Hodgson
wrote in 1873:
"I may as well attempt to supply the deficiency for the benefit of local inquirers, who, I suspect, are hardly sufficiently alive to that legerdemain of the closet-naturalist, whereby they are cheated of the whole merit of their labours by him who does no more than annex a few words of doggrel Latin to the numerous facts painfully elaborated by costly and continuous attention. How long assiduous local research is to be deliberately deprived of those aids of library and museum which it ought to be the chief duty of learned Societies at home to furnish, I know not. But the candid will, in the meanwhile, make all allowances for the necessary errors cleaving to attempts at technical Zoology, in the want of such aids. Whilst the face of our land is darkened with skin-hunters, deputed by learned Societies to incumber science with ill-ascertained species, no English zoological association has a single travelling naturalist* in India; nor has one such body yet sought to invigorate local research, numerous as now are the gentlemen in India with opportunities and inclination for observation such us need but the appropriate aid of those bodies to render the investigations of these gentlemen truly efficient towards all the higher ends which the Societies in question are constituted to forward !"
* The French, who are far quicker-witted than we Beotian islanders, have had two such agents in India ever since I came to it. But the travelling naturalist is in no condition to compete with the fixed local student, if the latter receive the obvious helps from home. For many years past we have had the great and wealthy Zoological Societies in London, which, however, have not yet found out that the phenomena of animate nature must be observed where they exist !
To this day, there exists no body that seeks to invigorate local research in India! Millions are of course spent on the the state forest departments, the ZSI, BSI and the GSI; government organizations that emerged from the interactions of these networks have all isolated themselves from mainstream research as well as from the public that supports them with taxes. And so ends this unfinished tale of connections in 19th century ornithology. This year happens to be the centenary of Hume's death and a commemorative event is scheduled in London next week. Perhaps some of my readers will be fortunate to be a part of it.
A growing series of postscripts
16-Aug-2013 Feilden in Burma seems to be
Henry Wemyss Feilden (1838-1921) [Ibis obituary 1921]
06-June-2014 The talks from the Hume centenary can be heard at the
SLBI website.
29-Jan-2015 R M Adam from Agra, also at Sambhur was Robert McNeiledge (or Macneilledge) Adam (1836/37 - 11 January 1913). He served in the Inland Customs department and was involved in salt taxes - in the same department as Hume. Seems to have retired around 1877 when he was working in the Madras Presidency(!) - appears to have been among those strongly opposed to the Ilbert Bill.
31-Jan-2015 - a note on Professor Harold Littledale from
The Cornishman 29 May 1930, p.6.:
Death of Dr. Harold Littledale
Dr. Harold Littledale, Emeritus Professor of English Language and Literature at University College, Cardiff died at his residence at Southbourne, Bournemouth on Sunday, May 11th, at the age of 77. He was the father of Mrs Clarence Paull of Roskear, Camborne. He edited various English texts, but his chief claim to remembrance is the influence he exerted on the problem of Indian primary education by the advice and guidance he gave the Gaekwar of Baroda in introducing to India soil the principle of compulsion.
Born to a Dublin solicitor on October 3, 1853, he was educated at Armagh Royal School and Trinity College, Dublin. Here he graduated in arts and was in 1876 senior moderator. in later years Dublin conferred upon him the degree of Litt.D. His best years were spent in Baroda State, where on the educational side he had a large share in bringing in the new progressive order following the deposition of Malaharao Gaekwar and the accession of the present Maharaj Sayaji Rao Gaekwar. He went out in 1879 as Vice-Principal and Professor of History and English Literature at Baroda College and his influence told in making the young ruler so keen in intellectual pursuits and conversation with the college professors. The two men formed a close friendship, and in later years Littledale was appointed Director of Vernacular Instruction in the State. It was while he held this post that the foundations were laid of the compulsory system introduced in Baroda many years before the principle found expression in the Statute book of any province of British India. The idea was derided as wholly inapplicable to Indian conditions; but it is now generally accepted in provincial legislation though its application is much restricted on financial and other grounds.
Littledale spent much of his leisure in Himalayan travel and the study of the flora and fauna of India making many valuable contributions to the "Journal" of the Bombay Natural History Society. He was a Fellow of the University of Bombay. Retiring from India after 20 years in Baroda he was appointed Professor of English Language and Literature at the University College of South Wales and Monmouth, Cardiff. In addition to his editing of various texts, he wrote occasionally on English literature and natural history. He was also interested in folkore. He was made Emeritus Professor in 1921.
---
January 2017 - Littledale married Annapurna Turkhud, second daughter of Dr Atmaram Pandurang Turkhud on 11 November 1880 (poor Tagore was also apparently in love with Annapurna!). Dr Atmaram Pandurang was one of the Indian founding members of the BNHS! Ana however died young and Littledale married again in 1892 - "A
marriage
will
shortly
take
place
between
Mr.
Harold
Littledale,
of
Baroda
College,
India,
eldest
son
of
the
late
Mr.
William
F.
Littledale,
of
Whaley
Abbey,
Rathdrum,
County
Wicklow,
and
Sybil
Frances
Hanbury,
fourth
daughter
of
Mr.
Edgar Hanbury,
of
Eastrop
Grange,
Highworth,
Wilts" - The Colonies and India, 24 Dec 1892. p.34
In August 2014, I visited the library of the Natural History Museum at London and examined two of the books by M.B.L. Cockburn and it turns out that the images found online do not show the pencil writings on the margin. The critical notes on the accuracy of the illustrations and other statements suggest that the books had gone through the hands of A.O. Hume. It may even have come into the NHM collections via Hume.
 |
A picture of Anthus similis by Miss Cockburn
In the corner in pencil - "I particularly want specimens"
|
 |
Pencilled "good"
|
October 2016: I visited the grave of Margaret Cockburn in Kotagiri along with Dr Henry Noltie. The graves of all the Cockburn family members are placed together.
5-May-2018: The somewhat young forest department (in the
establishment of which his cousin Balfour was involved) would have been a
good source for Hume to make use of but the only person who seems to
have contributed in some scale is T.F. Bourdillon. Hume named the eared
nightjar after him. A portrait of Bourdillon hangs at the teak museum at
Nilambur - the artist is unknown and it seems to show a few quills of
cinchona which suggests that Hume and Bourdillon may have also
interacted via the cinchona project (like with J.A. Gammie) which would have been within the
ambit of his department.
30-Jan-2020: Added an entry for E. Bonavia - a collaborator from Etawah.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emanuel_Bonavia
5-Apr-2020: Added an entry for the civil servant G.W. Vidal - a collaborator from the Konkan region, better known for his contribution to the game of badminton -
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_William_Vidal
5-Jul-2020: Added an entry for Hume's successor as secretary to the department of revenue and agriculture -
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_Charles_Buck
Captain A. Grahame Young (2 August 1834 - 2 November 1905) - buried at Jhiri, Himachal Pradesh seems to have also been interested in rearing Lepidoptera, Kulu folklore (communicated to the Asiatic Society of Bengal).
5-Mar-2022: Updated a Wikidata entry for Col. Maurice Tweedie (1838-1923), Superintendent of Police, Lucknow. https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q76201917
21-Mar-2022: Just noticed that my search for Hume coadjutors began in 2004 with an enquiry to the late Ed Moulton.
26 March 2022: Thanks to queries on several collectors / authors received from Aasheesh Pittie, I was surprised to see that many more than I had considered of Hume's collectors were directly under his official department - the inland customs - who were involved in collecting salt tax and doing patrols along the Great Hedge. These include Robert MacNeilledge Adam (R.M. Adam, 1836 - 11 January 1913); Walter (Charles) Nathaniel Chill (W. N. Chill; 27 March 1842 - ?). Adam, it would appear was actually from an indigo plantation family in Bihar (Tirhoot) and may even have been appointed into the salt commissioner position by Hume's influence after finding him a useful collector of specimens.
